| 1 | 
Act I: The Midway - Come Look at the Freaks - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 2 | 
Happy Birthday to You and to You - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 3 | 
I'm Daisy, I'm Violet - Jeff McCarthy | 
| 4 | 
Like Everyone Else - Emily Skinner | 
| 5 | 
The Devil You Know - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 6 | 
More Than We Bargained For - Jeff McCarthy | 
| 7 | 
Feelings You've Got to Hide - Emily Skinner | 
| 8 | 
When I'm By Your Side - Emily Skinner | 
| 9 | 
Say Goodbye to the Freak Show - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 10 | 
Vaudeville: Leave Me Alone - Emily Skinner | 
| 11 | 
We Share Everything - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 12 | 
Buddy Kissed Me - Emily Skinner | 
| 13 | 
Who Will Love Me As I Am? - Emily Skinner | 
| 14 | 
Act II: The Follies - Rare Songbirds on Display - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 15 | 
New Year's Day - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 16 | 
Private Conversation - Jeff McCarthy | 
| 17 | 
On the Road: One Plus One Equals Three - Hugh Panaro | 
| 18 | 
You Should Be Loved - Norm Lewis | 
| 19 | 
The Texas Centennial: Tunnel of Love - Jeff McCarthy | 
| 20 | 
Beautiful Day for a Wedding - Side Show Ensemble | 
| 21 | 
Buddy's Confession - Hugh Panaro | 
| 22 | 
Marry Me, Terry - Jeff McCarthy | 
| 23 | 
I Will Never Leave You - Emily Skinner | 
| 24 | 
Finale - Side Show Ensemble |